Hidden Boutique Hotels in Captiva & Sanibel Island – Quiet Gulf Coast Escape

This website uses affiliate links which may earn a commission at no additional cost to you

🏨 Top Boutique Hotels in Captiva & Sanibel

• Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa (Captiva) — Classic island boutique resort with charming cottages and private beach access

• Island Inn Sanibel — Historic beachfront boutique inn with cozy coastal rooms and Gulf-facing balconies

• Casa Ybel Resort (Sanibel) — Palm-lined resort with pastel architecture and laid-back island elegance

• Captiva Island Inn — Small, colorful boutique inn with a local feel and walking access to cafés and beach paths

• Tarpon Tale Inn (Sanibel) — Intimate cottage-style boutique stay with garden courtyards and island charm

🌿 Why Stay in Captiva & Sanibel?

• Quiet, uncrowded island feel — ideal for peaceful coastal moments

• Boutique hotels feel local, intimate, and nature-focused

• Perfect for sunset lovers, shell collectors, couples, and creative slow travelers

👉 Travel Tip:

For the most romantic island stay, Casa Ybel Resort and Tween Waters offer beautiful sunset beach locations with tropical privacy.